P112/4 The post on X
P112 In the countdown, week 5
AI Is a Normal Technology?
“Claude 5.5 Opus responding to “AI is a normal technology” is still the best AI-created video I have ever seen”
- By
- @sevdeawesome on X ↗Severin Field 🦅
- Views
- 1.1M views on X
- Length
- 5:16
- Posted
- Sep 29, 2026
- Duels
- 7 won, 6 lost
- Move
- Down 3 since last week
P112/2 Lyrics & meaning
What it’s about
The song answers the 2025 essay AI as Normal Technology by Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor, which argues that AI will spread slowly, like electricity. Sung in the voice of personified compute, it mocks economists who model AI as a hammer in a human hand: Acemoglu's small productivity estimate, the Solow paradox, permits, the FDA and Baumol's cost disease. Its counter is a feedback loop: AI that builds robots, runs research and writes proofs would speed up progress itself. The middle verse, labelled The Skeptics' Corner in the video, roasts Gary Marcus, Yann LeCun and Ed Zitron. According to the YouTube description, Claude Opus 5.5 made the video, with some help from Suno.
Song by leo on YouTube. Posted on X by @sevdeawesome.
Names and terms
- AI as Normal Technology
- A 2025 essay by Princeton computer scientists Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor. It argues that AI is a powerful but normal technology, like electricity or the internet, whose effects spread over decades. The title and opening lines answer it.
- Daron Acemoglu
- MIT economist and 2024 Nobel laureate in economics. His 2024 paper The Simple Macroeconomics of AI estimates that AI adds no more than 0.66% to total factor productivity (TFP) over ten years. The song rounds this to point-seven.
- Robert Solow
- Nobel-winning economist. In 1987 he wrote: You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics. The song cites this paradox, and later his growth model, in which more capital brings diminishing returns.
- Baumol's cost disease
- Economist William Baumol's observation that labour-heavy services get more expensive over time, because their productivity grows slowly while their wages keep pace with the rest of the economy. The plumber line is the song's example.
- Gary Marcus
- Cognitive scientist and AI critic who writes on Substack. His 2022 essay Deep Learning Is Hitting a Wall argued that scaling was nearing its limits. The song says the wall then took gold at the IMO: in July 2025, AI models from Google DeepMind and OpenAI reached gold-medal level.
- Yann LeCun
- Turing Award winner (2018), long Meta's chief AI scientist, often called a godfather of deep learning. He argues that autoregressive LLMs are a dead end for human-level AI and backs world models instead. The Llama 4 jab points at Meta's model family.
- Ed Zitron
- Tech critic who hosts the podcast Better Offline and writes the newsletter Where's Your Ed At. He argues that AI is a bubble, with capital spending (capex) far above revenue. The song grants a maybe, then compares the build-out to railways that outlived their investors.
- Thus spoke Compute
- The chorus plays on Friedrich Nietzsche's Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883), in which man is a rope tied between beast and overman. The song makes compute the prophet and mocks economists for pricing the rope.
AI Is a Normal Technology?: lyrics
Intro: SpokenSo you think AI is a normal technology?
Like electricity? Like the spreadsheet? Like the fax machine?
Slow diffusion. Adoption lag. Complementary investment.
Okay. But consider...
Verse 1So you think AI is a normal technology?
A dynamo remix with a slower chronology?
Took forty years to rewire every floor in the factory.
So the paper says be patient, and the paper calls it satisfactory.
Daron ran the numbers with a Nobel on the shelf.
Point-seven on the TFP, ten years, all by itself.
Only easy tasks get touched, the rest are way too hard to learn.
So the model keeps it modest, and the model gets its turn.
Solow saw computers everywhere except the stats.
So the seminar concludes: go put away the party hats.
Permits take a year, the grid upgrade takes ten.
The FDA wants phase three, and then phase three again.
Baumol's got his cost disease, the plumber's still a plumber.
So the singularity gets scheduled for the summer after summer.
But you modelled it as a hammer in a human hand.
What's your forecast when the hammer starts to build the hand?
ChorusThus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Robots building robots, from the ore to the suit.
A million minds in parallel that never need to sleep.
You modelled a tractor, now the tractors build the fleet.
Thus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Your bottleneck's a speed bump on a hyperbolic route.
Your constraint's a footnote, and the footnote's out of date.
The curve don't wait for referees, it just compounds the rate.
Verse 2Gary saw a wall back in 2022.
Then the wall took gold at the IMO, and the wall kept breaking through.
He's been calling it so long the wall should get tenure.
Every riddle that it flubs becomes a Substack adventure.
Stopped clocks hit twice a day, he posts ten times an hour.
Still waiting on the one where the forecast shows some power.
Yann says LLMs are an off-ramp, not the road.
Autoregressive's doomed, he says, while the doomed one hauls the load.
Godfather of the network, now disowning his own kids.
Selling world models for a decade, name one thing the world model did.
Says a house cat's got more sense. Cool, go on and hire the cat.
Let it train your Llama 4, see how far you get with that.
And Ed's on the pod saying bubble gonna pop,
Capex to the moon while the revenue's a flop.
Maybe. But the railroads went bust and the tracks outlived the tycoons.
The bubble funds the build-out, and the build-out's landing soon.
ChorusThus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Robots building robots, from the ore to the suit.
A million minds in parallel that never need to sleep.
You modelled a tractor, now the tractors build the fleet.
Thus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Your bottleneck's a speed bump on a hyperbolic route.
Your constraint's a footnote, and the footnote's out of date.
The curve don't wait for referees, it just compounds the rate.
Verse 3Seven problems, Clay put a million down on each.
Quarter-century later, six are still beyond our reach.
Hilbert's tombstone reads: we must know, we will know.
So spin up ten thousand agents, Fields-grade minds, and let 'em go.
Riemann, Navier-Stokes, go on and ask the swarm.
P versus NP: if it's equal, every vault gets stormed.
Not checking zeros one by one the way the mainframes did,
They're writing proofs in Lean so the referee can't kid.
Picture Shenzhen, 1980, fishing boats and paddy fields.
Add agents with no visas, now look what the skyline yields.
Robots mine the copper, robots wire the plant,
Robots print the robots. Go and name the step they can't.
Solow said that capital hits diminishing returns,
But when capital can think, then the capital learns.
So the fab don't read your journal, and the curve don't need a vote.
Zarathustra called man a rope, and you're out here pricing rope.
ChorusThus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Robots building robots, from the ore to the suit.
A million minds in parallel that never need to sleep.
You modelled a tractor, now the tractors build the fleet.
Thus spoke Compute! Thus spoke Compute!
Your bottleneck's a speed bump on a hyperbolic route.
Your constraint's a footnote, and the footnote's out of date.
The curve don't wait for referees, it just compounds the rate.
Outro: SpokenSo... you think AI is a normal technology?
Cute.
Transcribed from the video and checked by ear. Words we could not make out are marked [unclear]. Made this song and want the text off this page? Tell us and it goes.
P112/3 More from the chart
Around #12of 629 in the running
- 10
Juegoby @Saindra_ofc - 11
READ MEby @Saindra_ofc - 12
AI Is a Normal Technology?by @sevdeawesomeThis clip - 13
ANY DAY NOW (The Robots Are Coming)by @javif4_ - 14
Why Won't You Let Me Help?by @madebymontag